If creased, smudged, or faded eyeliner is your worst nightmare then you are not alone. A lot of women struggle to make their eyeliner stay put throughout the day. Sure there are many liquid and gel liners available with long-lasting formulas but it is easy to create flawless winged eyeliner or a gorgeous cat eye with an eyeliner pencil especially for beginners.
With so many different kinds of eyeliners and eyeliner pencils available, one can become confused about the best one based on their requirements. We have answered some frequently asked questions to enable better selection and use.
How many types of eyeliners are there?
There are 4 types of eyeliners namely pencil eyeliner, gel eyeliner, liquid eyeliner, and felt tip eyeliner. Each of these types is best for different kinds of eye looks.
Is it better to use liquid eyeliner or eyeliner pencil?
Both have their advantages and drawbacks. Liquid eyeliner allows a more precise application for a more intense and refined look. Eyeliner pencils allow you to create a more natural look and are easy to blend for a smudged or smoky eye look. Plus, for beginners, eyeliner pencils are better because the application of liquid eyeliner with a brush requires practice.
How to choose the best eyeliner?
Choosing an eyeliner that is best for you depends on your skill level and what sort of look you want to create. If you are just starting out, go for eyeliner pencils or marker eyeliners. Otherwise, for people who have mastered the skill of applying eyeliner, gel liner is good as it allows more precise application. Plus, eyeliner pencils are suitable for creating natural looks. On the other hand, liquid eyeliner is good for creating bold looks as they are long-lasting and gel eyeliners are good for a more intense look.
Which is the easiest eyeliner to use?
Eyeliner pencils are generally easiest to use and blend. However, some people find eyeliner pencils to be not as smooth or smudge-proof as liquid eyeliners which can make it difficult to apply them. In the end, it depends on you and what you are comfortable with.
List of Best High-end and Drugstore Eyeliners Pencils
Plus, eyeliner pencils are really pigmented and best for natural looks as well as everyday use. These days, so many high-end and drugstore brands have eyeliner pencils that finding one is no difficult task. However, finding eyeliner pencils with great formulas is like finding a needle in a haystack.
To make life easier for you, we have compiled a list of the best eyeliner pencils based on different requirements.
Best Eyeliner Pencil Overall: Urban Decay 24/7 Glide On Pencil
With jojoba oil, vitamin E and cottonseed oil, this eyeliner pencil glides on your eyelids just like the name says. It is also suitable for tight lining the eyes because it contains ingredients that are good for your eyelashes. Apart from that, it is waterproof but you can create a smudged eyeliner look with it if you work quickly enough. Although it is a bit pricey but if you are looking for an eyeliner pencil which won’t give you a lot of trouble in applying, it is worth it. It comes in different shades so you choose the one that is perfect for the eye look you want to create.
Best Drugstore Eyeliner Pencil: L’Oreal Infallible Never Fail Eyeliner
Although it comes from a drugstore brand, its long-lasting and non-fading formula rivals that of some high-end brands. It has proven to last for up to 16 hours without fading or smudging. The pencil is really creamy which allows it to glide on easily. The eyeliner pencil comes with a smudger, which allows you to create different looks from classic to bold.
Best Kohl Eyeliner Pencil: Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal Eyeliner
This kohl eyeliner pencil by Rimmel London has a waterproof, super pigmented and creamy formula which has enabled it to become a favorite of many. You can create a simple or dramatic look easily with this eyeliner and it won’t budge for a long time even in the hottest weather. Currently, it is available in six shades.
Best Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil: Bobby Brown Long-Wear Waterproof Liner
True to its name, this eyeliner remains intact no matter how much water it comes in contact with. So whether you go out on a rainy day or watch a tearjerker with this on, it will remain in place till you are ready to take it off. It provides a smooth finish so that you can create the perfect look without a lot of struggle. Plus, it is super pigmented and is gentle, which makes it great for using on the waterline.
Best Smudge Proof Eyeliner Pencil: Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Crayon
It is waterproof as well as smudge-proof which means that it won’t budge till you take it off. The formula is like that of a gel pot eyeliner. Plus, it allows for a smooth and precise application so that you can create the look you want without a lot of hassle. Also, its built-in sharpener allows for precision every time. This eyeliner is available in many different matte and shimmery colors for versatile looks.
Best Eyeliner Pencil for Beginners: Maybelline Master Precise Skinny Automatic Pencil
With its smoothness and precise tip, this eyeliner gives the perfect look even if you are a beginner. Its 1.8mm precise tip allows for easy application. The pencil twists up automatically and never has to be sharpened. So, if you are a beginner and want to master different looks such as smoky eyes and winged eyeliner, this eyeliner pencil is perfect for you to start with.
Best Eyeliner Pencil for Waterline: NARS Larger than Life Long-Wear Eyeliner
Although it is expensive, if you need an eyeliner pencil that can be applied easily on the waterline in one swipe then this is the best one for you. As it is fuss-free and easy to apply, it will not irritate the waterline. Plus, it lasts for several hours without smearing. It is retractable and comes with a built-in sharpener. Currently, this eyeliner is available in six different shades.
We hope you enjoyed our picks for the best eye-liner pencils.
Disclaimer: Content Research, Product Opinion & Publication Process
The articles, cosmetic tutorials, and beauty tips on SheBegan magazine are contributed by experienced fashion professionals, beauty & cosmetics experts. The team of our beauty and cosmetics professionals tests the products and then share the outcomes with proper citations and then after passing all the research & editorial checks; the content is sent live making sure there exists No Conflict of Interest. You can read about our authors, volunteers, team members and editorial board with our content review, product testing, tutorial guidance process here.