One of the problems that women face when it comes to heels is if they fit or not. How exactly do a woman know if their heels fit? I am sure this is one of the questions you have been wondering about. should heels be tight or loose?

No, neither too tight nor too loose is ideal for high heels. The right fit for high heels should secure fit around the foot and heel without causing discomfort. Also, the toes should not be cramped, and there should be enough room in the toe box for them to move freely.

7 Signs Your Heels Are Too Tight

Recognizing the signs that your heels are too tight is crucial for your comfort and foot health. Here are key indicators that your high heels may not fit correctly:

1. Pain and discomfort

The most immediate sign of too-tight heels is pain or discomfort, especially in the toes, sides of the foot, or heel area. If you experience pain shortly after putting the heels on, they’re likely too tight.

2. Marks and indentations

After removing the heels, look for red marks, indentations, or imprints on your feet. These signs indicate that the shoes are constricting certain areas of your feet.

3. Blisters and calluses

Frequent use of tight heels can lead to blisters or calluses, particularly around the toes and heels, where friction is most common.

4. Difficulty walking

Struggling to walk normally or balance properly in your heels can signal that they’re too tight, affecting your natural gait and comfort.

5. Numbness or tingling

Tight shoes can compress nerves in the feet, leading to numbness, tingling, or a sensation of “pins and needles” in your toes.

6. Toenail damage

Too-tight shoes can also cause toenail damage, such as bruising under the nail or ingrown toenails, due to excessive pressure on the toes.

7. Swelling

Tight footwear restricts natural blood flow, leading to swelling in the feet after wearing heels for extended periods.

6 Disadvantages of Wearing Tight Heels

The following are the disadvantages of wearing high heels that are too tight:

1. Foot pain and blisters

Tight heels can cause significant discomfort and lead to the development of blisters and calluses due to constant friction and pressure on the skin.

2. Bunions and hammertoes

Prolonged wearing of tight heels can contribute to the formation of bunions and hammertoes, which are painful deformities of the foot.

3. Poor blood circulation

Tight footwear restricts blood flow to the feet, leading to circulation problems, swelling, and numbness.

4. Posture and gait issues

Wearing tight heels forces the body into an unnatural alignment, affecting posture and gait, which can lead to back, knee, and hip issues over time.

5. Ingrown toenails

The pressure from tight heels can cause toenails to grow into the skin, leading to painful ingrown toenails.

6. Nerve damage

Constant pressure from tight footwear can compress nerves in the feet, leading to conditions like neuromas, characterized by pain, tingling, or numbness.

How to Know if You’re Wearing the Right Size High Heels

To know if you’re wearing the right size high heels, ensure they fit snugly without pinching or causing discomfort. There should be a small space between your longest toe and the shoe’s front, and your heel should not slip out when walking.

Comfortable arch support and a secure fit around the entire foot are crucial. If your feet don’t slide forward and you can walk without pain, you’re likely wearing the right size.

How to Choose the Right Heel Size

Choosing the right heel size involves ensuring a balance between fit, comfort, and style. Consider trying shoes on in the late afternoon when feet are typically at their largest.

Ensure there’s a little gap between the longest toe and the shoe front for movement, and the heels should snugly fit without slipping.

Walk around to check for any discomfort or pinching. Remember, proper arch support and a secure fit around the foot are essential for comfort and to prevent foot issues.


Is it better to size up or down in heels?

It’s generally better to size up rather than down in heels. This is because you can always add inserts or pads to improve the fit of slightly larger heels.

Should there be a gap when wearing heels?

Yes, but the gap should not be more than 1cm. A large gap can make heels slip off while walking. 


So, do heels need to be tight? No, they don’t. Good heels just need to be snug and not too tight. Wearing tight heels that are small for you can be detrimental to your legs in the long run. It is more advisable to go for your exact size, you can also check before buying online or in shoe shops in order to get your own size.

Disclosure: This article, other beauty and fashion tips on SheBegan are contributed by experienced fashion professionals, beauty & cosmetics experts. Read our full research and editorial process here. Also, our posts may contain affiliate links, read our full affiliate disclosure

Hi, I'm Praise and I will be taking you on a fashion journey. I am a full time writer, but I like to play dress-up by the side(winks). There are only a few things as beautiful as looking good and since we have established looking good is good business, I hope we can achieve that together.

Write A Comment

Pin It