Anyone who’s ever applied makeup knows of the eternal struggle to find a colour combination that works. With all the eyeshadow and eyeliner tutorials out there, it’s sometimes easy for people to get confused. However, the curiosity to know more and more about the latest trend and the kind of best colour combination that perfectly suits you makes most people ask if you can wear brown eyeliner with black mascara.

Yes, you can wear brown eyeliner with black mascara. With brown eyeliner and black mascara, you can draw attention to your lashes without making the rest of your eyes overly dramatic. The brown/black combo would be considered more of a casual look.

Should Your Mascara Color Match Your Eyeliner

When choosing a mascara, selecting one that blends with the color of your eyes is crucial. It would help if you chose your mascara based on the same criteria you use for other cosmetic products: it should enhance, not hide or alter, the natural beauty of your eyes.

Mascara is one of the most important products in your makeup bag. If you want to create a dramatic eye look, then mascara is the product for you. It can be used to add volume and length to your lashes as well as to define them.

When choosing your mascara, it is important to consider the color of your eyes. If you have brown eyes, you can choose any mascara that will enhance the color of your eyes. Choose black mascara for a more dramatic look if you have blue or green eyes. For redheads, stick with brown or black mascara.

To create a more natural look, try brown mascara with light-colored eyes and black mascara with dark-colored eyes.

READ ALSO: How Much Makeup Is Too Much?

For women with dark hair and eyebrows, brown eyeliner works well with black mascara because it enhances the contrast between your eyebrows and eyelashes.

Should Eyeliner Be Darker or Same as Brown


If you have brown eyes, you probably already know that the key to making them stand out is using the right eyeliner colour. The right colour will make your eyes pop and give you the desired look that you want.

For a natural-looking eye with brown eyes, choose brown eyeliner. A brown eyeliner adds dimension to the eyes, making them appear both rich and intense. However, if you want a sharp and sleek look, black eyeliner is always an excellent choice to combine with your brown eyes.

Eyeliner is one of the most popular makeup products. It can transform your look from drab to dazzling in a matter of seconds. The best thing about eyeliner is that it can be used on all eye colors and skin tones, making it an ideal tool for beautifying your eyes.

READ ALSO: Is Make Up A Lie? (Here’s the Truth)

The eyeliner comes in many forms. You can choose from liquid, gel, or pencil eyeliners. Regardless of which type you choose, remember that your eyeliner should complement your eye color and skin tone instead of overpowering them.

How to Choose the Right Eyeliner for Your Eye Color

Eyeliner is a very personal choice. It can make or break your entire look, so choosing the right one can be tricky.

Eyeliner is not just about looks; it should also enhance your eye color and shape. When choosing an eyeliner, consider whether you want to make your eyes look larger or smaller. If you have small eyes, avoid thick lines that will make them appear even smaller. On the other hand, if you have large eyes, then opt for a thinner line that will help shrink them down slightly. Here are some eyeliners that compliment common eye color.

1. Brown eyes

As many as 55-79% of people in the world have brown eyes. It is considered the most common eye color and comes with many variations like dark brown, light brown, and ambers/yellowish tinted browns such as honey or russet.

Brown eyeliner will work for you when you want something casual. However, black eyeliner is always an excellent choice if you want a sharp and sleek look. 

To make your brown eyes appear brighter, try colored eyeliner in shades that contrast with the color of your irises. For instance, think shades of midnight blue and teal, shades of olive and emerald green, shades of vivid purple and soft purple for a regal look, and even grey and charcoal to bring out any gold flecks in your brown peepers. 

2. Hazel eyes

About 5 per cent of people have hazel eyes, though this eye color is rare in many parts of the world. Hazel is a light or yellowish-brown color with gold, green, and brown specks in the centre.

If you have hazel eyes, you’re lucky. You can combine almost anything with Hazel’s eyes, whether it be browns, golds, greens, or purples, much like brown eyes. 

Hazel eyes are one of the most beautiful eye colors. They can look green or brown, depending on the lighting. Hazel eyes are usually a bit lighter than deep brown eyes, and shades of green seem to come through more in hazel eyes than in browns.

3. Green eyes

The color of your green eyes can be influenced by factors such as the type of makeup you wear, your clothes, and other things that affect your mood. To make green eyes stand out, use eyeliners in a complementary color that offers some contrast to the green.

Because green is the opposite of red on the color wheel, a complementary color range consists of all different shades of red, including maroon and brown-hued shades like burgundy or mahogany.

Violet and amethyst are also beautiful shades to complement green eyes. They add an earthy touch that can be striking on any eye color. When applying red or maroon eye shadow, it is best to use black eyeliner as a base. This will help you avoid looking pale and tired.

READ ALSO: Is It Weird For My Boyfriend To Wear Makeup?

4. Blue eyes

Choose complementary colors in rich and warm shades to make blue eyes stand out. Warm metallic like bronze or copper emphasize the golden flecks in blue eyes if applied appropriately.

Blue eyes are the most beautiful and vibrant, but they can be tricky to work with. The trick is not to overdo it. A smoky eye will look great on you because it will help to bring out the blue tones in your eyes. If you want a more dramatic look, colors with orange undertones, such as copper and gold, make blue appear more vibrant in contrast.

Should I Get Black or Brown Eyeliner

When you are choosing between brown or black eyeliner, think about how this choice will affect the appearance of your eyes. Brown eye color can be both dark and light. Both versions of brown add depth to the eyes, making them appear softer.

If you’re looking for a more subtle look, brown eyeliner is a good option. Brown is a natural color that blends in with your eye color and looks much more natural than black. Many women use brown eyeliner to only line the inside of their bottom eyelashes. This makes their eyes look bigger and more expressive.

Another benefit of using brown eyeliner is that it gives your eyes more definition without looking overly dramatic.

Black eyeliner is great for those who want a bolder look that stands out from the crowd. The eyeliner is also perfect for those who have very dark skin tones because it will make your eyes stand out even more than brown would do for your face. Black eyeliners come in many different styles and textures, so you can find one that works best for your needs.

The downside of wearing black is that it draws attention to tired eyes. Black eyeliner is trickier to apply than brown because black is a bolder color. Dark colors are more dangerous territory than warm neutrals.

Overall, knowing what you want and what best works or suits you is the key to choosing between black or brown eyeliner.

Is Black Eyeliner Aging?

Applying too much eye makeup, especially dark colors like black, can draw attention to wrinkles and fine lines around the eyes. Such hues look harsh and age you more than your actual age group would warrant.

Black eyeliner is probably the most common type of makeup on the planet. It’s been around for decades and is still popular because it makes your eyes pop. But if you’re over 40, you should be careful when applying black eyeliner.

There are a few ways to wear black eyeliner without looking older than you are. First, choose a softer shade of black to use as an accent color around your eyes instead of all over them. Then limit how much you apply by using only a thin line under your bottom lashes and one or two short strokes on your top lid.

Another trick is to add some brown shadow on top of the black liner for a softer effect.

Does Brown Eyeliner Make Eyes Look Bigger?


Using brown eyeliner to make your eyes look larger will give you a sultry, sleek appearance. Many brown eyeliners will make your eyes look bigger and brighter. You can also achieve an eye-widening effect when pairing brown eyeliner with lighter colors, like white or light pinks.

Brown eyeliner is a great way to add color and definition to your eyes. The color has been around for centuries, but it’s making a comeback in the beauty industry today. Brown is a versatile color, which can be applied lightly or heavily depending on your preference.

Also brown is one of the most attractive colors for humans because it looks good on everyone! Brown is also very flattering against light skin tones and dark skin tones alike, which makes it very versatile when choosing an eye shadow color.


In the end, you can wear brown eyeliner with black mascara for a more dramatic look. However, only you can decide which eyeliner looks best with your particular eye shape. Experimenting is the best way to see what works and what doesn’t. You can keep on trying new looks until you run into a combination that’s the right one for you. Then, once you find that perfect mix of brown eyeliner and black mascara, stick with it.

Disclaimer: Content Research, Product Opinion & Publication Process

The articles, cosmetic tutorials, and beauty tips on SheBegan magazine are contributed by experienced fashion professionals, beauty & cosmetics experts. The team of our beauty and cosmetics professionals tests the products and then share the outcomes with proper citations and then after passing all the research & editorial checks; the content is sent live making sure there exists No Conflict of Interest. You can read about our authors, volunteers, team members and editorial board with our content review, product testing, tutorial guidance process here.


Abimboye Femi is an experienced Beauty Expert. Over the years, he has developed an uncanny nose for sniffing out the perfect fragrance as well as an eye for best beatification practices. He brings to bear, his vast knowledge of research to help deliver rich contents centered on Beauty and Cosmetics.

Write A Comment

Pin It